You knew that before, I know. I had thought that he would have terminated therapy long before. Letting go of her is not the same thing as forgettingand nobody is asking you to throw a switch. I was now convinced it was important to answer Penny right back: when I stayed tough, she got more resilient. I had no distractions (in those halcyon days before e-mail) and have never written better or more quickly. Indeed, the capacity to tolerate uncertainty is a prerequisite for the profession. Yet Penny had gotten what she had set out to get: therapy, free of charge, from a Stanford professor. Marvin listened to ten minutes of our initial interview with great interest, smiled at me, and said, Who is that jerk, anyway?, Marvins quip has a serious side. What does Yalom think about patients first statements? Or else theyll talk about it aswhat is it called when the therapist transfers something to the patient?, Yes, countertransference. Within seconds after seeing him, before he said a word, I was aware that he had profoundly changed: the old Saul was suddenly back with me. But I might as well have been talking to the wind. Youve thought that maybe he was trying to drive you to suicide. She hated the doctors who had told her that Albert was doomed. The Four Gives of Life For example, during one hour when I was reminding him of how much gratuitous teaching he had given to the Stockholm Institute fellows and junior faculty, he stated that, as a result of what he had done to these bright young students, he had set the field back twenty years! Also, it helped that you didnt get into your role of the wizard letting me guess about questions you know the answers to. So I then attempted to help her work on her life situation, but I could make little headway. I was reduced to prescribing Marie sedation sub rosa. And if I eradicated the illusion, then I had to be prepared to encounter the despair it had concealed. To what extent would we agree? Lets see, how does it work? She talks to Dr Yalom about how she is married and she had an affair with a previous therapist named Matthew. After finishing this book, I turned to another interest that had long been percolating under the surfacethe role of existential concerns in human life and human distress. Her tight shoulders relaxed, her face loosened, her head turned ever so slightly toward me. First breathe deep and fast; then well gradually slow it down. She had never had a positive relationship with a man, and it is possible her sons had paid the penalty for that. No problem. His lymphoma, he said, was killing him in stages. I mean exactly what I said. Should I ask harsh existential questions of a dying man, a widow, a bereaved mother, and an anxious retiree with transcendent dreamsquestions for which I have no answers? By that time, her anger toward Dr. Z. had rusted away, and she forgot about her resolution to raise her voice against him. "If Dr. C only knew what really happened." I tried to rattle and shock her. They had already driven off, but she jumped into her large, souped-up pickup and followed them at high speed down the highway trying to ram them off the road. The judges would be thrown into disarray. Matthew, her previous therapist who was an intern. Sex, itself, didnt play too important a role., This helps us understand the dream you had a couple of weeks ago.. At the onset of therapy, Betty had indeed wanted only the trim painted but had been drawn inexorably into reconstructive work on the deep interior of the house. And I guess you can say Ive found a way to take them with me! The stark images took form immediately in my own mind. When I think about what to do, I often hear your voice asking rational questions. He had met her while he was managing a branch of an American company in Beirut. At least for someone who finds people and their motivations and the reasons behind the development of their quirks and personalities to be interesting. But that moment, Carlos continued, I had a vision of their naked hearts. Was I walking into a trap? I was glad to run into Thelmainto you, Thelma, turning to her. .) demonstrate that though the fact, the physicality, of death destroys us, the idea of death may save us. Though she continued to take it, it had not helped her: she was deeply depressed, cried every evening, wished she were dead, slept fitfully, and always awoke by four or five a.m. She moped around the house and on Sundays, her day off, never dressed and spent the day eating sweets in front of the television set. I posed questions, at first gentle and gradually more challenging. She and he had increasingly diverging views about religion, and she could not follow his conversion into a fundamentalist Christian sect. Life doesnt seem worth living. She had underlined with red pencil a paragraph that claimed that suicides are, in actuality, double homicides. I took my time and thought out my words carefully. Details are wonderful. In that event, his wife would find the letters and be pained by reading them. She had made it clear that she would not commit herself to long-term treatment; and, besides, I thought that I should know within six months whether I could help her. Penny knew that next time around she would be luckierperhaps richer. My parents arrived in the United States in their twenties, penniless immigrants from Russia. Marvin said he finally understood a dream: the dream meant that he had turned women into goddesses and then believed he would be safe if he could appease them. I was irritated with Marvin. I really want the group to be helpful to you, and I think it best that we do it this way: Ill be glad to store the letters in a safe, locked place for as long as you wish, provided that you agree to tell the group about our bargain.. What was it that happened to Elva that she thought, "I never thought it would happen to me"? My last physical exam was over fifteen years ago., Another group member: You look like youre in great shape, Dave, whatever your age., Thank you. Rationalizing a truth during therapy is not effective. We both know our joint venture may not have been our finest effort but, for me, the important thing is it afforded the opportunity to know you personally after knowing and respecting your work for thirty years. The ruminations were highly repetitious: most were a fairly faithful replay of any one of their meetings during the twenty-seven days. My eating is out of control, Betty said, chuckling, and added, You could say my eating is always out of control, but now it is really out of control. He was glad I was seeing you. No, she hated groups. If the situation demanded itfor example, if family members visited from out of town Phyllis was willing to entertain them in a restaurant: An inexpensive restaurant, since Phyllis hates to spend money. Money was another reason, Marvin added, that she opposed psychotherapy. There she was cowering behind her chair as Marge was wont to do when frightened. I fumbled for words of comfort. There was little of Matthew in it, norif love is a caring, giving, need-free relationshipmuch love. Im the only person there with enough guts to tell the truth. She gave the thumbs-down signal and one gray morning took Elmer on his final visit to the veterinarian. How had they felt about their father abandoning them? Besides, Ive read your books for years. Maybe I was wrong, but I think her eyes said, Are you satisfied now? I did not comment on her gaze. I have to find a way to live out my time. Right here. She pointed to her heart. The moment had come to play my final card. In addition to the stresses she had described to me on the phone, there had been others. But why? Try again. Exactly whats happened to you? The fact that Penny was in crisis, or said she was, presented me with a dilemma. Did he have a message for me? No response from Thelma. Often therapy doesnt work that way. Dr. K. responded, I cant prevent you, of course, but I consider it ill advised. She was speaking more deliberately, in a bitter, forlorn tone, but there were no more tears. It has been translated into twelve languages and is now in its fourth edition. We talked about her widowhood, her changed social role, her fear of being alone, her sadness at never being physically touched. Bettys body had remembered what her mind had long forgotten. Youve got to make a place where she can live: thats what fathers dothey build a world for their children. I shall have to take medicine the rest of my life. I was certain that she understood me perfectly. And there with her face in spasm, like Quasimodos, horribly distorted, barely able to talk. Lets be very realisticas you say, this is the place to be honest. I want you to focus on one thing, nothing else. Obviously, Thelma was responsible for her own life predicament. My negative feelings about obese people prevented me from achieving the deep engagement that I believe is necessary for effective therapy. Chicago / Turabian - Author Date Citation (style guide) . Harry, unable to sleep that night, phoned Thelma back and grew alarmed at the continual busy signal. I also realized there are certain disadvantages in being too energetic. He was trying to make a point to her, but she was looking away from him. Im not sure I know what youre talking about. But I got greedy. To my great surprise, Carlos made excellent use of therapy; and after six sessions, we agreed to meet in ongoing treatment. I war against magic. The person who has fallen in love, and entered a blissful state of merger, is not self-reflective because the questioning lonely I (and the attendant anxiety of isolation) dissolve into the we. This letter was too devastating. What do you want me to do with them? I asked. It was with much sadness that Thelma said goodbye to him. Id been warned that you psychiatrists did that regardless of the problem. Not only did I believe that I could help Thelma but I was intrigued by the idea that this counterfeit love could be a beacon that might illuminate some of the deep mystery of love. What happened then? Twenty-six times four is one hundred and four a minute. 4 Ratings 19 Want to read 1 Currently reading 5 Have read Overview View 5 Editions Details Reviews Lists Related Books Publish Date 2000 Publisher Perennial Classics Language English Pages 286 It was pointless to begin by addressing her weight. Here the letter broke off. (Thelma in "Love's Executioner") revolved around the theme of surrender to a former lover (and therapist) and my search for strategies to help her reclaim her power and freedom. He was sitting there patientlya short, chubby, bald man with a glistening pate and owl eyes which never blinked as they peered through oversized, gleaming chrome spectacles. Penny, you talk to Chrissie every day. Perhaps he overheard scraps of my discourse with the dreamer. But that she could not, or would not, do and fiercely resisted all my attempts to energize her will. A rugged, brawny woman: weathered, battered, proudand trembling. Ive been in therapy once removed. But too much was riding on this hour. The irony of it all. I stressed that it would not be possible, because of other commitments and travel plans, to meet for more than six weeks. In fact, I noted with surprise the first stirrings of empathy within me. I doubted that I would find the answers to these questions. I asked her about the conditions of her life, but she couldnt talk about that. Yet, if I revealed these things, Dave would feel betrayed and probably leave therapy. I focused on the anxiety. I recommended reading material and urged her to visit a female gynecologist and to explore these issues with her girlfriends and her therapy group. Analysis revealed seventeen central properties, which organized five reciprocal, interactive categories. The day Betty entered my office, the instant I saw her steering her ponderous two-hundred- fifty-pound, five-foot-two-inch frame toward my trim, high-tech office chair, I knew that a great trial of countertransference was in store for me. Why today?, To celebrate my victory. But the problem is that sex is turned into something medicinalno, thats not strong enoughsex becomes a life or death proposition, and your survival depends on merging with this woman. In fact, throughout the session he remained deeply empathic. We started going faster and then went up into a big arc in the sky. In an effort to console her, I tried to suggest that losing control is not always a catastrophe. First, she responded in a teasing way (I told you all along thats what I needed). I felt it. I wanted to linger with the dream but had to return to the needs of the moment. Sorry you have to hear this whole thing yet again, Thelma.. She undressed me and then took off all her clothes.. Why had he rejected her and cast her out? I was not certain what would happen in this extraordinary three-way meeting, yet I felt strangely confident that all would be for the best. It occurred to me that I was performing a thankless task. The message:He is building up a case against you. We know that. We considered the men in her life: a father (faded from personal memory but forever reviled by her mother) who deserted her, through death, when she was eight; her mothers loversa lineup of unsavory night characters who vanished at daybreak; a first husband who deserted her one month after their wedding, when she was seventeen; and a cloddish, alcoholic second husband who ultimately deserted her in her grief. I hear only human feelings. Well, I can keep it very brief. She suspected Matthew was gay: he lived in one of San Franciscos gay enclaves, and was beautiful in the way many gay men are, with his neatly combed mustache, boyish face, and Mercury-like body. Thankfully, times have changed. I wasnt certain. It was clear that a direct appeal would be of no value. Perhaps he felt that the letters would lose their power if he shared them with others? Sometimes, as in Pennys family, the surviving children suffer because so much of the parents energy is bound up with the dead child, who is both memorialized and idealized. We did not know, then, that it was to be a permanent farewell. No wonder sex has been difficult. But its very upsetting to hear him talk about remodeling rooms so he can display his various collections. I never saw Blush (or Brazen) again. Then he rose from his chair and paced about in my office, gulping air in great draughts. I put it, also unopened, on top of the first one in the same desk drawer. It was my idea to invite Matthew, my idea to ask him the questions you did. I thought I saw her nod her head. She lathered him in the shower, she shaved him, she massaged him, she took his soft penis into her mouth and held it there gently until it throbbed into life. I didnt know what Marvin would do, nor did I know how else to help. When you keep asking me impersonal questions, as you did a few minutes ago, I feel pushed away., This is exactly the sort of thing Matthew used to say.. An illustration of an audio speaker. Had he made a mistake in thinking I was sensitive enough to help him? Im too advanced for it., Everyone is dishonest and playing games there. Thelma thought about him continuously, not an hour passing without some prolonged fantasy about him. Thats beautiful! Im not sure when it started. Your advice about couples therapy made sense to me. What did I do? After your suicide attempt, I knew I had to be very careful with what I said, and thats why I became so distant. While plenty of patients may need sexual affirmationthose who are markedly unattractive, extremely obese, surgically disfiguredI have yet to hear of a therapist affirming one of them sexually. My children dont need any money. The closer she approached that weight, the more depressed she grew and the more her mind swarmed with feelings and recollections of her father. Most likely she would reconstruct the hour with Matthew so that her version of reality could once again support her fusion fantasy. Her stutter always annoyed me. Not only did it explain his defensiveness at work, but he could extend this disidentification model to pertain to his body. After all, what can the man do to me? He merely shook his head. Anyway, we started making love. But hiding them didnt accomplish anything. What happened in that hour to throw you like this?, What a fool I was to have protected him for eight years!, Thelmas anger enlivened her. I resolved to give him everything, to give in to him on every issue. Remember how great you felt about yourself two weeks ago? I didnt like the sound of that. I knew we were both chased by the same man with a rifle. Just what I tell my students. Moreover, the painter- therapist had sprayed deathher fathers death, her own deathinto her house. kitchen island wood tops; By ; In shelby county court case lookup; red dead redemption 2 hdr game or cinematic . What do you do with your problems? Marge had appropriated the bold parts of the other Marge as I urged her to do, and it was important that I be receptive and respectful to each of her questions. Why do we, I mused, pursue these unfavorable comparisons? Earlier Penny had told me that she was in frequent communion with Chrissie, visiting her daily in the cemetery and spending an hour a day grooming her grave and talking to her. Professionally, he regarded it as a successful consultation. Look, give yourself a break. Without a ripple. Although Thelma's love obsession with her therapist, and her subjective experiences on life of what is preventing her from living in the present, Yalom attempts to treat a 70-year-old woman only to learn that being love executioner more complicated as he had anticipated. Review articles, Saul knew, age quickly, especially in fast-moving fields like cellular biology. All this cloak and dagger! But these were my reflections, not Marvins. And therefore, as John Donne wrote, never send to know for whom the bell tolls; it tolls for thee.. Though charmed by her ingenuous compliment, I was made uncomfortable by both thoughts: the mysterious somehow, and the vision of me as a miracle worker. That was the top priority in my life then; that was why I had advertised for volunteers. When I was a child, one of my favorite booksI used to take it to Lincoln Park in Washington, D.C., to read on the benches therewas. Sometimes she came into my office in tears after a week without food and no compensating weight loss. Six months later, he received a rejection notehis first in twenty-five yearswhich explained, with deference considering the stature of the authors, why the journal could not publish the article: in the previous eighteen months, three other competent reviews of the same literature had been published, and, furthermore, preliminary research reports published in the last few months did not support the conclusions Saul and Dr. K. had reached about promising directions in the field. I dont know how seriously to take himeveryone in California is such a health nut. As you seeshe ran her fingers through her uncombed hairI no longer tend to my appearance.. No! I told myself, shaking myself free. In an effort to reduce her anxiety, I urged moderation and suggested she approach sex with less drastic steps: for example, by spending time talking to men; by educating herself about such topics as sexual anatomy, sexual mechanics, and masturbation. And then it goes away again! That cartoon was apt for Carlos, except that he had not one, but repeated episodes of clarityand they always went away again. When you and I first began to meet, we had a brief flurry of talking. The past, the true story, the chronicle of real events, is unrecoverable. She then kept on going and massaged my back, then my legs, and then my penis. After a decade of study and research, I wrote a textbook, Existential Psychotherapy , intending not to establish a new field but to make all therapists more aware of existential issues. Your call would drop my chances to zero, or less.. Maybe youd like to get some caring from the group, but how can you get it when you come on so tough? There was a gypsy camp forming right in the front lobby of my office. I really did, but I cannot. There is no alternative. The obsession filled her entire life space. Above all, I wished to protect and maintain our relationship. Impossible, I insisted, and posed the same question many different ways. That means youll be running late all day, doesnt it?. . When Im depressed I get impotent, and then because Im impotent I get more depressed. But, in milder form, countertransference insinuates itself into every course of psychotherapy. The power of fusion has been demonstrated in subliminal perception experiments in which the message Mommy and I are one, flashed on a screen so quickly that the subjects cannot consciously see it, results in their reporting that they feel better, stronger, more optimisticand even in their responding better than other people to treatment (with behavioral modification) for such problems as smoking, obesity, or disturbed adolescent behavior. As always, I feel isolated hereprofessional colleagueship is scarce at the Stockholm Institute. It was not hard to understand why Elva clung to the feeling that Albert was still there, out back in the workshop looking out for her, fixing things. The surgeon admits that was true. When Saul was seven his parents had died in an automobile accident, and he had been raised by an aunt and uncle. But I was careful to tread a fine line. I am surprised that the food is so good. (Like many patients, Carlos became deathly ill and despondent during chemotherapy.) How well did it heal?, He suggested that perhaps I was too young to appreciate how many eight-year-old boys auditioned unsuccessfully for the Quiz Kids., Feelings dont always follow rational rules. She considered termination to be an attack upon meand she was right! To treat someone as an equal implies an inequality which the therapist must overcome or conceal by behaving as though the other were an equal. You know, Im not trying to conceal anything. I decided upon a general strategy: my basic position would be that I wanted to get closer to her but that her behavioral traits got in the way. She was down to two hundred forty pounds, then two hundred thirty, and two hundred twenty. I never heard anything about them since. Ive gone over all the pros and cons, and I now believe you are rightIm in such bad shape that its not likely anything could make me worse!, Thelma, those arent my words. Weve agreed to meet for a chat every month or so.. Perhaps it is more accurate to describe therapy as treating the patient as an adult. I was impressed by two things: you were clearI could understand your writingand you were willing to speak openly about death. At any rate, I wish to dissociate myself from the work.. You called me a dozen times a day. Yet, despite their promises, the whole financial burden of the plot was falling on her shoulders. That was the peak of my life. , , . It reminds us of life passages. Beware of stripping a patient who cant bear the chill of reality. Would it have been better not to have spoken of the letters and to have let the dream go? Someone is accusing him of being involved only in the transplantation process and being uninterested in all the messy circumstances of how he got the heart from the donor. As for Marvin? It takes away the depthit makes it into nothing. So I agreed to treat her because I was certain she was suffering, not from love, but from some rare variant which she mistook for love. My secretary said she always could tell by my smile that I had seen Elva that day. In this instance, for example, if he hadnt been desperate for Dr. K.s approval, he would have avoided the whole problem by doing what any collaborator doessimply keep ones co-author informed about all developments in their joint work. There is almost no chance hell say what I hope hell say. I insisted that we had made real progress. We agreed to concentrate on maintaining her new weight of one hundred sixty and, to that end, Betty bought a whole new wardrobe. . We sat in silence together. Over forty years ago, she had made a contract with life whose explicit genesis and terms had been eroded by time but whose basic nature was clear: Albert would take care of Elva forever. That seemed to help. I had nothing but good feelings for her. doing it. Another reason we can never fully know another is that we are selective about what we choose to disclose. Everyone treats me that way. Youve elevated him to a superhuman position. No, no, no! He said he had orders to paint everything, inside and out. Howd you do? I inquired cheerily, keeping up my side of the conversation. Of the thirty-five people who phoned for an appointment, Penny was the first. I sighed even more deeply. Together these two belief systems constitute a dialectictwo diametrically opposed responses to the human situation. Several things, he said. I care about what happens to you. Ive had other therapists who tried to be warm, to put you at ease, but Matthew was different. If I multiplied every sign of stress by ten, I would have it: his willingness to pay fifty thousand dollars; his morbid, suicidal ruminations (he had made a serious suicide attempt five years before); his anorexia; his insomnia; his request to see me sooner. Rather, love is a way of being, a "giving to," not a 'falling for"; a mode of relating at large, not an act limited to a single person." Much of her therapy had been obtained at the local county mental health clinic, where she had been treated by a series of trainees. Why open it? It seemed to me that an important lesson Betty could learn from an awareness of death was that life had to be lived now; it could not be indefinitely postponed. Loves Executioner is a collection of ten true stories (identifying details have been changed to protect anonymity, of course) of patients in psychotherapy with Irvin Yalom and how his work with them progressed. Think of your hand as a storehouse of numbness. She had worked and worried Matthews statement that he cared for her until it now seemed an insult. Never have I felt so keenly the dual role of the therapist as participant-observer. Why not? Marvin took himself very seriously: he was practically my only patient with whom I could never joke or banter. Yet I had started therapy with intense negative feelings about Bettyfeelings I had never discussed with her and that she had never recognized. But he had overstepped himself. The lilt was gone from her voice. Did things just work out that way? Such isolation is to be distinguished from two other types of isolation: interpersonal and intrapersonal isolation. But then, in my naivet, I thought it outrageous, unnatural, something that had to be put right. He cried in my office that day. She kept her head down but nodded almost imperceptibly. No distracting questions, no jocular clichs, no struggling to stay on the surface. Since guilt seemed to be the primary problem, I set about, for the rest of the two-hour interview, learning as much as possible about Pennys guilt. Yet I had little difficulty accepting those patients, attempting to understand them, and finding ways to be supportive. I just fear were heading toward trouble. What would you most like me to do?, I know Ill be all right in a few days. I could hear each spurt splatter against the waxed walls of the cup. But you must promise me one thingthat you wont call Matthew without my permission.. I could picture her with one side of her handsom face horridly disfigured by grimaces and spasms. Surely this was an unusual opportunity for her to obtain therapy from an experienced clinician. Nietszche said, The final reward of the deadto die no more. Yet here was also a wonderful opportunity to work on our relationship. As our third hour drew to a close, there was no longer any point in pretending that Penny was not in therapy with me. . I think it also means being young again., Weve talked very little about your feelings about being seventy. Her tongue, always visible, changed radically in size as it darted in and out or circled her moist, rubbery lips.

93 North Accident Methuen, Articles L